5 Investing Mistakes That Can Quietly Derail Your Long-Term Plan (and How to Fix Them)

Feb 3, 2026 | Risk & Diversification

Investing doesn’t usually go off the rails because you picked the “wrong” stock once. More often, it’s the repeatable habits—emotional reactions, neglected maintenance, and avoidable drag from taxes—that compound into real damage over time. 

Below are five common mistakes and simple ways to correct them without overcomplicating your strategy.

1) Bailing out when the market gets scary

When markets drop or headlines get loud, it’s tempting to “pause” investing and move to what feels safer. The problem is that rebounds can happen fast—and if you’re out of the market during the recovery window, the long-term cost can be huge. One example cited: missing just the best 5 market days over a long period reduced gains by about 37% in a hypothetical scenario. 

Better move:

  • Build an allocation you can emotionally tolerate in downturns (see Mistake #2).
  • Decide in advance what you’ll do in a selloff (keep contributing, rebalance, and ignore the noise unless your goals changed).

2) Taking on too much risk—or not enough

Risk isn’t optional in investing. Take too much, and you may panic-sell at the worst time. Take too little, and your portfolio may struggle to grow enough to meet long-term goals or keep up with inflation. 

A key insight: how you split money across broad categories (like stocks, bonds, and cash) can explain a large share of how a portfolio behaves over time (the article cites research suggesting asset allocation can explain up to ~90% of return variability in certain contexts). 

Better move:

  • Choose a risk level that lets you stay invested through volatility.
  • Diversify so different parts of your portfolio don’t all move the same way at the same time. 

3) “Set it and forget it” without rebalancing

Even if you start with a good mix, markets will push your portfolio off target. A strong stock run can quietly turn a moderate portfolio into an aggressive one; a bond rally can make you more conservative than intended. 

Better move:
Pick a rebalancing rule you can follow:

  • Calendar rule: rebalance every 6–12 months, or
  • Drift rule: rebalance when allocations move more than a set amount (example: ±5%).

Rebalancing is basically portfolio maintenance—it keeps risk aligned with your plan. 

4) Paying more in taxes than you need to

Taxes are part of life, but many investors pay extra simply because they don’t realize what’s triggering the bill—like capital gains distributions, selling appreciated investments unnecessarily, or holding tax-inefficient assets in the wrong type of account. 

Better move:
Consider tax-aware habits such as:

  • Tax-loss harvesting (when appropriate)
  • Tax-efficient “asset location” (placing certain investments in accounts where their tax treatment is more favorable) 
  • Minimizing unnecessary turnover in taxable accounts

Even small annual tax savings can compound into meaningful differences over time. 

5) Going it alone when you’re stuck

Self-directed investing can work well—especially with a simple, diversified plan. But if you notice patterns like panic-selling, constant strategy switching, or never getting around to rebalancing or tax planning, it may be worth getting help. The article cites research estimating professional advice can add value over time depending on how it’s measured and applied. 

Better move:
Ask yourself:

  1. Do I have the skills to manage this well?
  2. Do I have the time to keep up with it?
  3. Do I actually want to manage it? 

If any answer is “no,” even a periodic check-in with a professional can help you stay on track.

A simple “anti-mistake” checklist

  • I won’t make big moves based on scary headlines. 
  • My risk level matches my goals and my stomach. 
  • I have a rebalancing rule and I follow it. 
  • I’m not donating extra money to taxes by accident. 
  • If I’m consistently off track, I’ll get support.